IB

View all Questions

Question

Physics

What happens to angular speed when an object lands on a spinning disc?

Answer

Physics

Expert Answer

The disc slows when the arriving object adds moment of inertia without bringing angular momentum about the axle. Moment of inertia measures how strongly an object resists a change in its rotation. During the brief landing, conserve angular momentum about the axle; do not assume rotational kinetic energy is conserved.

For a uniform disc of mass MM and radius RR, initially rotating at ωi\omega_i,

Id=12MR2.I_d=\frac12MR^2.

A compact object of mass mm that sticks a distance rr from the axis adds approximately mr2mr^2 to the moment of inertia. Suppose it falls vertically, with no initial sideways motion, onto a horizontal disc. Its initial angular momentum about the vertical axle is then zero. If the external torque about that axle is negligible, through conservation of angular momentum

Idωi=(Id+mr2)ωf,I_d\omega_i=(I_d+mr^2)\omega_f,

so

ωf=IdId+mr2ωi.\omega_f=\frac{I_d}{I_d+mr^2}\omega_i.

Friction produces opposite torques, or turning effects, on the object and disc. It transfers angular momentum from the disc to the object without changing the system's total. A fixed axle can exert a force without exerting a torque about its own axis. The presence of this friction causes losses in the rotational kinetic energy.

Consider a 2.0 kg2.0\,\mathrm{kg} disc of radius 0.30 m0.30\,\mathrm{m} rotating at 12 rad s−112\,\mathrm{rad\,s^{-1}}. A 0.50 kg0.50\,\mathrm{kg} object lands at r=0.20 mr=0.20\,\mathrm{m} and sticks. Then

Id=0.090 kg m2,If=0.110 kg m2,I_d=0.090\,\mathrm{kg\,m^2},\quad I_f=0.110\,\mathrm{kg\,m^2}, ωf=0.0900.110(12)=9.82 rad s−1.\omega_f=\frac{0.090}{0.110}(12)=9.82\,\mathrm{rad\,s^{-1}}.

Check energy separately:

EKi=12(0.090)(12)2=6.48 J,E_{Ki}=\tfrac12(0.090)(12)^2=6.48\,\mathrm{J}, EKf=12(0.110)(9.82)2≈5.30 J.E_{Kf}=\tfrac12(0.110)(9.82)^2\approx5.30\,\mathrm{J}.

About 1.18 J1.18\,\mathrm{J} of the initial rotational kinetic energy becomes other forms during slipping and sticking, such as internal energy. This calculation only compares rotational energy: the energy from the object's vertical fall must be accounted for separately.

There is a useful algebraic check: at fixed angular momentum, EK=L2/(2I)E_K=L^2/(2I), so EKf/EKi=Id/If=ωf/ωiE_{Kf}/E_{Ki}=I_d/I_f=\omega_f/\omega_i here. Increasing II reduces both speed and rotational energy.

Landing nearer the rim causes a larger slowdown because the added inertia depends on r2r^2. Landing exactly at the centre adds no inertia in the point-mass approximation, which treats all the object's mass as concentrated at one point. If the arriving object already has tangential velocity (motion along the circular path), include its signed initial angular momentum mrvtanmrv_{\mathrm{tan}} before solving; the disc need not slow down.

Have a go at the disc-and-dropped-object problem in the IB Physics space, time and motion questions (Question 162). Can you use the object's landing radius to work out its added moment of inertia and choose the final angular speed?

Answered by Revision Village IB Expert

Interested in diving deeper into this concept?

Explore More IB Physics Resources

Over 80% of IB students globally are experiencing the power of Revision Village